SCV Talk · Archive
Nine years of the Valley’s town square · 2006–2015
SCV Talk
June 18, 2013· santaclarita.com · SantaClarita.com (SCVTalk 5.0) · Wayback capture

Tiburcio Vasquez : Latin Robin Hood or bandit/murderer?

Great piece in the Times today on rising power of the Latino vote in Central California, a theme I suspect we'll see played out in many communities -including the SCV- in decades to come.

Image not recoveredtiburciovasquezportrait.jpg
The piece is about Salinas, California, a farm town dating back to the Chumash, mentioned by Steinbeck in the Grapes of Wrath, and now populated by whites on the wealthy west side of town, and Latinos on the poor east side of town. Into this has stepped a fiery Latino politician named Jose Castaneda, whose popularity with the Latino base has seen him win a seat on the school board and the City Council, simultaneously.

Castaneda is unapologetic about his dual roles and is fighting efforts to get him to resign from the school board where he was instrumental in naming a new elementary school "Tiburcio Vasquez Elementary School."

Castaneda and other Latinos like him, are taking a fresh look at Vasquez, the handsome Californio bandito who hid out on the rocks in Agua Dulce that now bear his name, before he was caught and hung in San Jose 100+ years ago.

Educated, handsome and a charismatic ladies' man who wrote poetry, Vasquez the bandit became a celebrity during an era of social and economic upheaval in California.

His exploits — robberies, shootouts, eluding authorities — spawned countless newspaper articles, tell-all books, even a play during his life, which ended in 1875 when Vasquez was convicted of murder by an all-white jury and hanged.

"To the whites, he was an evil Mexican. To Latinos, he was a Robin Hood," said John Boessenecker, a San Francisco lawyer and historian who wrote a biography of Vasquez. "He was a symbol of hope and resistance."

Here in Santa Clarita, I'm rather proud of the way we treat Vasquez. If you read SCV history at all, you'll see that, unlike President Bush, we do "do nuance" when it comes to thinking & writing about Tiburcio Vasquez.

I credit the various part time historians who have looked after our local our history for decades with the more nuanced view. Sure we still think of him primarily as a bandit, but a simple browse of SCVHistory.com shows other sides of the man. Here's one of my favorite anecdotes from a 1965 magazine portrait of the Californio bandit:

A stage rumbled over the Hollister-New Ibria Mines Road in the late California afternoon. The shotgun guard dozed with the shiplike roll of the coach.
As the horses rounded a sharp turn, six armed riders blocked the way. One man grabbed the left lead horse's rein. Another bandit aimed his heavy rifle at the driver's head.
He was dark, handsome and slender.
"All right, senors, drop the express box."
He gestured with the rifle.
"Then get your passengers out."
A woman leaned from the carriage window. Her long blonde curls fell from beheath a plumed hat.
"Tiburcio, is that you?"
She shielded her eyes from the sun glare.
Tiburcio Vasquez, Central California's most successful bandit of the 1870s, glanced from the guard to the handsome woman.
"Senora, I didn't know you were traveling today."
"Tiburcio, we have the miners' payroll. Please don't take it. Those poor men will not be paid if you do."
Vasquez raised his sombrero and smiled. Then he turned to the driver.
"You are lucky to have such a passenger. Drive on!"
Vasquez's companions swore silently as the coach rolled away.
"For why did you do that?" one demanded.
"Ah, amigo, who can resist a lady so lovely. Besides she saved me from a sheriff once. There will be another stage."
That was the nature of Vasquez, the bandit and lover.


Our own Jerry Reynolds, who wrote SCV history in the 1990s, echoed that account:

This game of cat-and-mouse continued until May 14, 1874 when a posse surrounded the desperado, capturing him at the Hollywood Hills home of camel driver "Greek" George Allen. The Greek was away at the moment, unwittingly leaving his wife to entertain Vasquez.
Los Angeles went wild when "The Scourge" was brought into town, stretched out on blood-stained hay in an ox-cart. After he was tossed into a cell, someone brought Vasquez a bottle of whiskey, which he cheerfully accepted and, with the first gulp, toasted the president of the United States.

Gushing ladies presented him with bouquets of flowers. A photographer set up a camera, took some pictures and hawked them on the street for twenty-five cents each. The Life of Vasquez played to standing-room-only audiences at the Merced Theatre, where the principal actor was coached by Tiburcio, who even loaned him his clothes. Everyone wanted the outlaw to play himself — everyone but Billy Rowland.
Vasquez was transferred to San Jose where he was convicted of murdering a hotel keeper during the Trés Piños "outrage." 

He was hanged March 19, 1875, at 1:35 p.m. His last word was "pronto."

Whatever your view of Vasquez, I think it's fair to say he was a complex character in a very complicated and strange time in California's history. It's a time most of us are strangely disconnected from here in 21st Century California; I think California's history, the relationships of its people (natives, easterners, the Spaniards & Mexicans) get scant attention in our public school curriculum, and that's a shame. California during the 19th Century is rich with history, at least as interesting if not more interesting than what occurred on the east coast in the 18th Century or during the Civil War in the 19th. 

This Castaneda fellow sounds like a crooked politician through and through, but he's touching a nerve in the Latino community, and with at-large elections becoming tougher and tougher to defend around the state, we might see more like him sooner rather than later.


Tiburcio Vasquez : Latin Robin Hood or bandit/murderer?

Comments (10)

  1. SantaClaritaDotComTuesday, June 18th, 2013 at 12:33 pm
    Robin Hood is almost 100% hero. Maybe Vasquez should be considered more like a Bonnie & Clyde, or Jesse James. Charismatic, romanticized, and fun to read about, but not exactly a role model.
  2. PreflyteTuesday, June 18th, 2013 at 1:01 pm
    I see Castaneda's point. I kinda like Vasquez too, but he is a terrible role model for children. That is the point of naming a school after a historic figure, right? To inspire students. Otherwise, Bugsy Siegel Middle School will be next. He was handsome and charming, too. There are many positive Hispanic figures in California history that would be great choices for school names. There are schools already named after some of these people, and more are welcome. Choosing to highlight a criminal is grandstanding, and not helpful to anyone but Castaneda, which makes him seem more of a Hispanic Ron Paul.
  3. Leon WordenTuesday, June 18th, 2013 at 4:56 pm
    Let's not forget Vasquez High School in Acton. We beat central California to the punch.
  4. SamTuesday, June 18th, 2013 at 8:06 pm
    http://www.tvhc.org/AboutUs/History.aspx
  5. Leon WordenWednesday, June 19th, 2013 at 3:48 am
    Interesting. Didn't know about that one. "Vasquez was a bold, flamboyant risk-taker who won the hearts of many Spanish-speaking early Californians and Native Americans. Legends among the communities that loved him have painted a portrait of a romantic poet, a caring and giving man who often provided food and medical aid to the needy, and a passionate supporter of human rights." Sort of one-sided in the opposite direction from our one-sided 1950s history books?
  6. evitalc31Tuesday, June 18th, 2013 at 2:14 pm
    I, too, think of Vasquez in the light of Jessie James. Being Latino myself, I have raised my daughter to be proud of people like Dolores Huerta.
  7. Timothy Myers, Sr.Tuesday, June 18th, 2013 at 2:33 pm
    The Robin Hood comparison is a bit strained. For one, Robin Hood is the perfect fictional character (and he is fictional) who finds himself dispossessed of property since he is a member of a discriminated minority who MUST resort to banditry to pay the bills. More likely comparison is with Jesse James. Initially James of (sort of) fighting the Civil War with Quantrell, but then after the war ended kept to banditry because he could not earn an honest living. In the case of Vasquez Californios were definitely discriminated against but could still earn an honest (and even prosperous) living with effort. Vasquez took the easier path of banditry. With regard to the general disinterest in California history, there was just not enough (white) blood shed. The natives were eliminated with VERY minimal white casualties and the Civil War never touched the state. When visiting Fort Tejon I must wonder at how lucky the federal troops stationed there during the Civil War must have felt, just enjoying the pleasant weather and not having to participate in the blood bath east of the Mississippi.
  8. Leon WordenTuesday, June 18th, 2013 at 3:17 pm
    Hi Jeff! Nice job. Whether one castigates TV as a murderer or considers him a rebel with a cause, or perhaps a bit of both, I think it's instructive to consider this, in his own words ...... and remember, California was part of Mexico until 1848; the USA was just another foreign country until it declared war in 1846; TV was born in 1835; his people were defeated by foreign aggressors: "My career grew out of the circumstances by which I was surrounded. As I grew up to manhood, I was in the habit of attending balls and parties given by the native Californians, into which the Americans, then beginning to become numerous, would force themselves and shove the native-born men aside, monopolizing the dance and the women. This was about 1852. "A spirit of hatred and revenge took possession of me. I had numerous fights in defense of what I believed to be my rights and those of my countrymen. The officers were continually in pursuit of me. I believed we were unjustly and wrongfully deprived of the social rights that belonged to us. So perpetually was I involved in these difficulties, that I at length determined to leave the thickly settled portions of the country, and did so...." Full piece =< http://www.scvhistory.com/scvhistory/truma You muscle in on my women, there will be hell to pay. =;-<
  9. evitalc31Tuesday, June 18th, 2013 at 5:56 pm
    I really enjoy the extra information. I love history and find discovering SCV history very fun.
  10. evitalc31Wednesday, June 19th, 2013 at 7:26 am
    I learned more about history on my own rather than in school. My daughter reads a lot of history books on her own time and discovers so many things about her Latino heritage. I enjoy history books when they are a neutral as possible.

Preserved as part of the SCV Talk Archive. Text is presented as originally published; presentation has been standardised for readability. The original capture is available at the Internet Archive.

Support